ORDER SHEET
IN THE HIGH COURT OF SINDH BENCH AT SUKKUR
Const. Petition No.D-4675 of 2016
Date |
Order with signature of Judge |
1. For hearing of CMA
No.14202/2016
2. For hearing of CMA
No.13233/2016
3. For hearing of main
case
17-04-2018
Mr. Mehboob
Ali Sahito, Advocate for petitioners
Mr.
Mehboob Ali Wasan, Assistant Advocate
General
.-.-.-. -.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-
The
learned counsel for the petitioners has made his submissions at length. His
main contention is that petitioners are entitled to get the requisite
appointment letters for the post of Police Constable in the Police Department.
On the other hand learned AAG has invited our attention to the parawise comments of respondents No.2 and 4. As per these
comments the minimum criteria fixed for qualification of test was to secure 40
marks. As per these parawise comments 12 petitioners
out of 31 since secured requisite marks therefore appointment letters were
issued to them. The names of 12 petitioners are also mentioned in the parawise comments.
Though
the learned counsel disputes the above contentions of respondents by further
arguing that the remaining petitioners have also secured reasonable marks and
that is the reason they were called for interview and went under medical
examination.
We are
not impressed by the submissions of learned counsel representing the
petitioners as parawise comments are quite
comprehensive and specific, besides the written test was taken by Institute of
Business Administration (IBA), which is a very credible institution. More so 12
petitioners have already been appointed against the vacancies of Police
Constables and no plausible reason is there in the defence
of other petitioners, that they were discriminated
against. Consequently this petition, in this view of the latter development has
no merit and is accordingly dismissed with no order as to costs. However it is
clarified that those petitioners who are at present unsuccessful and could not
get appointment letters may apply afresh in accordance with prevalent rules and
regulations, as and when new vacancies are announced.
JUDGE
JUDGE
Suleman Khan/PA